How to Reheat Papa John’s Pizza in the Oven (The Papa Johns Way)

Who isn’t a fan of pizza! The majority of people will agree that there is nothing a pizza can’t cure. 

A hangover? Stress? Exhaustions? One solution to all of these is a pizza.

One of the pioneers of the US pizza scene is Papa John. You cannot go without saying their name. 

Not only they are one of the oldest chains of pizza restaurants in the country, but also the maker of dipping sauce. They introduced the dipping sauce for your warm fluffy crust, that you otherwise have left in the box.

But what happens when you have a papa John’s pizza from the night before? How to reheat Papa John’s pizza in the oven?

We are going to talk about Papa John’s way and also the traditional way.

Instructions on How to Reheat Papa John’s Pizza in the Oven

There are clear instructions from Papa John’s about how to reheat their pizza in the oven. This is because they want you to enjoy their signature pizza even after it is left in the refrigerator.

So how do you reheat the pizza? Here are the instructions

Step 1: Bring Out Your Pizza

If you have left your pizza in the refrigerator, bring it out and let it come down to room temperature. Because if you pop it in the oven right away, some parts of it will be soggy and some will be burnt.

Step 2: Pop the Pizza in the Oven

When your pizza is at room temperature, simply place it in the oven. And then turn the oven on to 350°. No preheating of the oven is required.

Step 3: Enjoy

After about 10 minutes, your pizza will be done reheating. It will be heated equally depending on how many pieces you have left. 

Note: This method is ideal for a whole or a half of a Papa John’s pizza. This is why there is no preheating is needed. As you are heating up the whole pizza, this method is effective to get the gooey center with the crispy crusts.

Reheating a Slice of Papa Johns Pizza

Not all of us leave half of the pizza unfinished. Leaving a piece or two is the civilized way. 

Jokes apart, if you have less than half of a Papa John’s pizza, you have to go the traditional way of warming it up.

Step 1: Preheat the Oven

Preheat the oven to 400°. Yes, we are going to preheat the oven as there is not much volume of pizza to keep the moisture in it.

Step 2: Place the Pizza Slice in the Oven

Put the pizza slices in the oven. And let it do its job for 5-10 minutes. Check occasionally for your liking or any burns.

Step 3: Enjoy

After your pizza is reheated to your liking, take it out and enjoy it warm.

Pro Tip: While heating up a pizza in the oven, use a pizza stone or steel. This ensures the pizza gets crispy underneath while the toppings stay moist. You can also go for a baking tray if you don’t have a pizza stone or steel. Do not place your pizza directly on the oven racks.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best way to reheat Papa John’s pizza?

The best way to reheat your Papa John’s pizza is to put it in the oven. The oven heats your pizza from all sides making it heat up evenly. If you don’t have an oven, a microwave can do the same thing. But if you don’t have any of those, a stovetop will work. But remember to start with low heat and a lid on top of the pan you are using to reheat your pizza.

Can you reheat Papa John?

Yes. You can always reheat your leftover Papa John’s pizza. Simply put the pizza in the oven and then turn it on. There is no need for preheating your oven. The temperature should be set at 350°. And after 10 minutes, your pizza will be done. 

What is the best way to reheat leftover pizza?

The best way to reheat your leftover pizza would be to put it in an oven of 350°. This will give you a soft and fluffy crust along with melted toppings. But if you opt for a crispier crust, then 450° is the best way. Remember to place your pizza on a pizza stone, steel, or a baking sheet instead of the oven rack.

Conclusion

The nostalgia and the warm feeling of a Papa John’s pizza are undoubted. There can be a lot of different fancy places that serve warm and authentic pizza. But a leftover pizza is nothing compared to those. It’s like a warm hug of happiness that surrounds you when you have a pizza late at night or in the morning. Make sure you use the proper method to reheat your Papa John’s pizza. Or you won’t get the real taste you have desired.